The Conversion of Phenomena to Theory: Lessons on Applicability from the Early Development of Electromagnetism
نویسنده
چکیده
theories of modern physics, and the increasingly mathematical arguments used in their development, has led some to see the success of modern physics to seem mysterious or even magical. Looking at the development of equations in quantum theory, Steiner (1998) has argued that as a result of their being developed using various kinds of mathematical, rather than physical, analogy, their significant success in applications presents a challenge to a naturalistic explanation of the applicability of mathematics. The challenge to naturalism is supposed to come as a result of mathematics being anthropocentric. I will argue in a later section that this argument is problematic for several reasons, which are evident once we better appreciate how mathematical theories of nature are developed out of experience. The successful application of the theories of modern physics cannot be properly understood through a consideration of their development alone; one must also examine the process of development of the low level theories used in their construction. A proper understanding of the manner of the connection of physical theories, modern or otherwise, to phenomena requires at least a basic understanding of the connection of the theories to their origins in direct experience. An appreciation of the full depth of the connections of theory to experience, and hence the role played by experiential phenomena in their development, may serve as a basis for examining the connections of theory to phenomena beyond experience. This is because understanding the connections to experience will enable an elucidation of the reasoning used to develop theoretical characterizations of phenomena beyond experience, which should provide means for a clarification of the connection between the given theory and the natural phenomena to which it applies. The difficulty in studying theory development from the point of view of understanding the relationship of physical theory to experiential phenomena is that the low level physical theories used in the majority of cases of mathematical modeling in the physical sciences have a long and complex history. Generally speaking, tracing the full connection of the mathematics of a physical theory to experiential phenomena becomes increasingly complex the more recent the theory. For example, although certain experimental anomalies were key in the development of (non-relativistic) quantum mechanics, the theory has its roots in classical mechanics, classical electrodynamics and thermal and statistical physics, which have their own complicated connections to experiential phenomena as a result of their process of development. Further difficulty arises from the fact that these theories, in turn, were developed in part on the basis of prior theory. Thus, examining how knowledge of experiential phenomena is used to develop theoretical characterizations of phenomena beyond experience becomes quite a complex affair. This is not to suggest that understanding how theory relates to phenomena requires a full appreciation of the entire development of science. This is just to point out that modern physical theories have a deeply complex relation to the phenomena to which they apply as a result of the manner in which they, and importantly also the theories used in their construction, are developed. It is also to point out that developing a better understanding of the relationship of physical theories to natural phenomena requires a thorough look at how the low level theories in the physical sciences were developed. The physical theories of the 19th Century are of particular interest from the point of view of understanding the relationship of physical theories to natural phenomena. This is in part because it is the theories of this century that form the basis for much of modern physics
منابع مشابه
Universal Health Coverage and Primary Healthcare: Lessons From Japan; Comment on “Achieving Universal Health Coverage by Focusing on Primary Care in Japan: Lessons for Low- and Middle-Income Countries”
A recent editorial by Naoki Ikegami has proposed three key lessons from Japan’s experience of achieving virtually universal coverage with primary healthcare services: the need to integrate the existing providers of primary healthcare services into the organised health system; the need to limit government commitments to finance hospital services and the need to empower providers of primary healt...
متن کاملThe Theory of “Living Time ” in Periodization of Iranian Architectural History
The writing of Iranian architectural history has, from its start, followed the principles of western historiography. Portions of this history are well expected to be neglected or unattended when writing of it takes place outside its intellectual framework that essentially reflects the Iranian throught world. To have a truly Iranian architectural historiography, one has to find the theoretical p...
متن کاملThe Feasibility and Applicability of Grounded Theory Methodology in Translation Studies: Developing Translator Competence
The development of sociological approach to the study of translation makes it possible for the researchers to adopt different methodology to develop new theoretical formulations and concepts. These formulations are arrived at through the interaction with those being studied through the interpretation of real social world and meanings of the participants involved in the translation/social event....
متن کاملInvestigating the Effect of Selected Sustainable Development Indicators on Credit Allocation: the Case of National Development Fund of Iran
Credit allocation through the usage of Portfolio optimization mainly seeks tomaximize return and minimize the risk of the portfolio; but there are other importantissues including sustainable development which is important for government/publicsectors. This paper presents a novel credit allocation approach based on portfoliooptimization and investigates the effects of selected indicators of sust...
متن کاملControl Theory and Economic Policy Optimization: The Origin, Achievements and the Fading Optimism from a Historical Standpoint
Economists were interested in economic stabilization policies as early as the 1930’s but the formal applications of stability theory from the classical control theory to economic analysis appeared in the early 1950’s when a number of control engineers actively collaborated with economists on economic stability and feedback mechanisms. The theory of optimal control resulting from the contributio...
متن کامل